https://teaching.blog.gov.uk/2016/02/23/a-whole-new-marking-system/

A whole new marking system

Shaw Primary Academy in Thurrock has implemented a new marking system that allows teachers to check every book quickly and efficiently.

Headteacher Dawn Copping outlines the straightforward changes she introduced to eliminate the need for teachers to mark books at home.

I was inspired to try something different in September 2013 because of some interesting observations made in my role as a headteacher and in my previous role as an assessment leader in another school.

I had discovered over the years that when you compare excellent teachers, who could be described as ‘terrible markers’ in terms of adhering to school marking policies, with those who spend hours of their time writing lengthy comments, suggestions and questions in books, you don't necessarily see any difference in outcomes for pupils.

Dawn Copping, Chair of the Marking and Policy Review Group
Dawn Copping, Chair of the Marking and Policy Review Group and Headteacher of Shaw Primary Academy in Thurrock

I noted too that teachers often describe marking as their biggest workload challenge, so much so that they are often forced to ‘ignore’ some pupil books because marking them all is simply impossible. This often results in hard working teachers feeling guilty and under pressure to achieve the unachievable.

With all this in mind, and tiring of enforcing a system of marking that I did not believe in, I decided that enough was enough and set about creating a policy that eliminated the need for distance marking.

Signs and symbols

The new system involves signs and symbols allowing teachers to quickly and effectively mark pupils work during the school day. Written feedback is now only given by teachers if they have worked with that child in the lesson and they do so there and then.

At the end of each day each teacher compiles a summary sheet (a single side of A4) highlighting specific actions they will take in future lessons (such as working directly with a child, changing their group, offering some advice, providing more challenging work etc.). If a pupil features in the summary sheet there is a specific symbol placed in their book. Our pupils have got used to this and know to ask the teacher what they need to do differently.

Our marking system ultimately ensures that feedback to children is instant and has impact, every piece of work is valued and formative assessment is reliable and informs future planning. Pupils and teachers have played a huge part in the ongoing development of the policy and their views and ideas were listened to and incorporated during our trial year.

My teachers have unanimously told me that their workload is significantly reduced and have pointed out the added advantage of system that has improved their ongoing assessment of children's current standards and what they need to do next. They use what we call our 'DM sheet' as an aide memoir that ensures they give purposeful feedback, give praise and plan challenge or support on an individual basis to all learners in their class. The system is so efficient that teachers are able to check every book for every pupil every day.

Improved work-life balance

It would be foolish to say our system is perfect and, as with all things, there is always room for improvement. We will continue to monitor and evaluate it, just like every other policy and practice we undertake.

What I can say with absolute certainty however, is that the teachers in my school have a considerably improved work life balance. They have more time to plan engaging and exciting lessons and although they still get tired because they work incredibly hard, they know that the hours they do devote to their professional life are valuable and have impact on the children they work with.

One of the greatest joys of developing and implementing this practice happened during the last few weeks of July this year. I had the pleasure of seeing my NQT skip into school ready for her early start, excited about getting her class ready, labelling her books, setting up her book corner and embarking on all the delights that make teaching the best job in the whole world!

I was able to look at her bustling about in the early days of her career, knowing that that she will not become resentful about pointless workload, will not be bitter about not being able to join her non-teaching friends on a mid-week night out and best of all, will not be considering leaving the profession in the first few years after graduation.

Sign up to email updates from this blog

Read more about the Workload Challenge

10 comments

  1. Matt Priestland

    This is really helpful and inspiring. Thank you!

    Link to this comment Reply
  2. Whil de Neve

    Fantastic work on the review, Dawn. Well done. This has made a world of difference at Cromer Junior School.

    Link to this comment Reply
  3. Sarah Ellis

    This sounds fantastic. Is your marking policy in your website so I can have a closer look?

    Well done for being brave enough to make a change. X

    Link to this comment Reply
  4. K. Gartside

    Your review was refreshing and your marking policy for Shaw Primary Academy sounds inspired. Is there any way we can see the policy and / or DM sheet? I've looked at your website but can't find it there.

    Link to this comment Reply
  5. Heck

    I would also be very interested in seeing the marking sheet please. It sounds very interesting and it has been endorsed on this government web site - so examples would be hugely appreciated!

    Link to this comment Reply
  6. Helen McDaid

    I would also be really interested to see the policy and DM sheet- it sounds far more focussed and less labour intensive than the one we use at present.

    Link to this comment Reply
  7. Helen Sehne

    I too would be interested in your policy and DM sheet. Thanks

    Link to this comment Reply
  8. Sian Mills

    Where can you see an example of the marking signs and symbols?

    Link to this comment Reply
  9. J Needs

    YES please! may I see the examples? thanks in advance

    Link to this comment Reply
  10. lynne Smith

    How do we go about seeing this in action? Could we see examples please?

    Link to this comment Reply

Leave a comment